Tuesday, September 4, 2012

The Njenje Dossier: The Meticulous Performance Assessment Outcomes of Orlando Pirates Coach

Never in my wildest dreams could I have imagined that Augusto “Njenje” Palacios will be a newsmaker of the week since he left coaching a professional soccer team donkey years ago but Dr Irvin Khoza gave him a second chance to restored his coaching skills and now all the bus stops, taxi ranks, corridors, pathways and beer hall talks are about Augusto Palacios. This Augusto palacious talks have eclipsed his 2011/2012 Premier Soccer League Championship accolade achievement with Orlando Pirates.

Let me give you a brief history about Professor Augusto Palacios - he is one of the coaches who played fundamental role in developing South African football in post-apartheid South Africa after SAFA was re-admitted to FIFA family in 1992 which was a major milestone to the South African football.

Augusto Palacios coached Bafana Bafana from December of 1992 until he was replaced by Clive Barker in January of 1994. Just to refresh your memory, Palacios coached 8 Bafana games. He won 3 games lost 3 games and drew 2 games. Bafana managed to score 6 goals and concede 9 goals. His best game for Bafana was on 16th January 1993 when Bafana Bafana played 0-0 draw against African giant Nigeria. However, the legitimate goal scored by George Dearnaley was ruled offside and robbed Njenje a massive two points by then which is now 3 points for a win

Njenje as Augusto Palacios is famously known is an expert who has passion to unearth young talent. His achievement with Pirates Under15 includes the success of reaching the Finals of the Manchester United Premier Cup Finals played in England in 2011. Personally, Njenje is a good coach but his tactical soccer acumen is obsolete to contest with emerging generation of local coaches with tactical acumen like Steve Kompela, Gavin Hunt and many other emerging coaches.

Njenje represents the older generation of coaches like Screamer Tshabalala, Jeff Butler, Clive Barker, Shakes Mashaba, Trot Moloto, Kenneth Kubheka, Ted Dumitru, Jomo Sono whom I will never appoint as the PSL Coach because their coaching philosophy is irrelevant to the modern game but they can be a valuable asset to head any Youth Development Structure of the PSL teams.

Let me not digress from the subject matter of the day, When Palacios was appointed Orlando Pirates Head Coach on a permanent basis, he confessed that he is happy that the chairman trusts his knowledge in football and capacity to lead a big club like Pirates. He further said that he would not have done justice to himself if he had failed to thank the players for the great spirit displayed and ability of working as a family last season.

In his own words, “I want to promise the club fans that I will continue to work hard next season. His declarations after accepting the most difficult job in the African Continent inspired confidence to many Pirates supporters as in their eyes he was seen as the messiah who won the league under difficult circumstances last year.

The question many soccer fans are asking is ’’what went wrong for the Orlando Pirates ‘’hero coach” to become an Orlando Pirates ‘’zero coach” overnight?

Let the truth be told, the tactics and techniques of Palacios are incongruously for a team of Pirates calibre. His average and predictable tactical methodology of enjoying playing from within of the pitch accompanied by an ineffective wing play is turning Pirates into a mediocre team. Pirates always dominated ball possession in almost all the games they played but they failed to translate balls position supremacy into goals.

After 4 games, Pirates hasn’t scored a single goal. They already played 374 Minutes including referees optional time without scoring. Only goalkeeper can achieve 374 minutes milestone without conceding a goal but if a team achieved such milestone, it means the team is a candidate for relegation.  

Palacios system has already failed Pirates this season but to every fan’s amazement, Njenje is continuously using his system as he lacks Plan B to change the game around. Under Palacious, the reigning PSL champions have been far from impressive, in 6 matches, Pirates won 2 (one of the win include that squeaky win against Celtic in the MTN 8), lost 2 and draw 2 but all the lost was within a space of 7 days in their own backyard slaughter house (Orlando Stadium) which is a rare moment as Pirates hardly lost at home.  Pirates are not looking like a team that will defend their title. It’s not raining but pouring at Orlando Pirates. There is a visible tactical crisis and the ship is slow but surely sinking.

Augusto Palacios Tactical Challenges
1.         Palacios lacks plan B to change the game around when the team is under siege. His delay of substitution tendency is working against the team as he is forever giving ineffective players sufficient time in the field of play instead of replacing them with effective players.
2.         Njenje favouritism is tearing apart team spirit. Some players are treated unfairly despite their enormous talent.  Some players are always finding themselves in the starting line-up despite out of form performance. Daine Klaite is a great player but he is now out of form and deserves to be rested. Tlou Segolela is an appropriate player to replace an ineffective Klaite.
3.         The rotational system in the goalkeeping department won’t work at all. The team should have a steady goalkeeper. Goalkeepers gain confidence by playing but rotational system breaks the confidence of the goalkeepers as they easily lost momentum by sitting on the bench than playing. Even today, I don’t even know who is the reserve goalkeeper of Iker Casillas at Real Madrid? Best team in the world doesn’t believe in a rotational system of goalkeepers. Njenje should stick with a reliable first team keeper than rotating Moneeb Josephs and Senzo Meyiwa which is not yielding any positive results.
4.         Thabo Matlaba is an effective left winger with an impressive offensive techniques but playing him out of position has resulted in many goals conceded in the right back position. He is always caught off-guard as he is not comfortable at the right back.  Palacios should introduce Happy Jele as he is ready to play. Jele will revitalise his form by playing than sitting on the stand.
5.         The defence of Pirates is uneven as the coach is always playing different 4 at the back especial at the left back. To have a common understanding at the back, Njenje should have 4 reliable defenders that he will use at all the time. The defence should remain the same as chopping and changing which make the team vulnerable from ruthless attacks of the opposition team.
6.         The current wing play is non-existed as Klaite is failing to deliver the anticipated crosses whilst Sifiso Myeni enjoys cutting the field than delivering crosses which is now limiting goal-scoring abilities. The team made a biggest blunder by releasing Dikgang ’’Terminator” Mabalane who is an exprience master of wing play with blistering pace and infinite crosses to strikers. Whoever, took a decision to release Terminator Mabalane despite his talent require the mental observation at Weskoppies psychiatric hospital in Pretoria West. It was poor decision at the highest degree.
7.         Andile Jali is a great player but he is currently tactical ill-discipline by over doing things. He is now a “’Neymar”’ of Pirates as he is forever holding onto ball too much through his unnecessary dribbling at his own half which is too dangerous and costly if they seize balls from him at danger-zone. AJ15 is South Africa best anchor-man who must play according to coach instructions than playing tsiki-tsiki kind of football. Don’t get it twisted, Andile is Orlando Pirates outstanding player this season but needs to get rid of his unnecessary dribbling by KISS (keep it straight and simple).
8.         The striking force is toothless as they are unable to convert changes into goals. Pirates strikers should be calm, collected and persistent in-front of goals. The composure is lacking as they are forever missing goals that are easy to score than to miss but praise should be given to strikers for good positioning as they always find themselves which is a good signals for goals to come in the forthcoming games.
9.         The ill-discipline of players is affecting team spirits to fight in collective manner. Rooi Mahamutsa and Benni McCarthy “childish act” and ‘’Prima Donna antics” are costing the team. The two players are part of the spine of the team and should focus on playing than misbehaving in the field of play which resulted in dismissal to all of them. The duos are role models to many youngsters and I wonder what kind of messages they are conveying to the emerging talents.
10.      Pirates are lacking creative players to unlock the opposite team’s defence. They have Mark Mayambela who has been crucified for making some silly mistakes. However, mistakes are part of the game and just like any other player in the team, Mayambela deserves fair chance.
11.      The future looks bleak with Palacios in charge. I don’t foresee any further miracles under Njenje who is lacking modern football tactical acumen. My conscious and objective analyses are hereby declaring the state of tactical calamity at Orlando Pirates FC.

In conclusion, Palacios can’t shoulder the blame alone; players are also responsible for poor performance especial missing of clear cut goal opportunities but losing games are part of the football but it is not the signal of the end of the road. Palacios (if he remains the coach at Pirates) needs to go back to drawing board to revisit, re-evaluate and review his tactical philosophy which is not working at the moment. His tactical philosophy should be embedded on the principle of fairness and transparency by selecting his starting eleven based on merits than reputation.

Management of Pirates are to be blamed for signing many players without any needs assessment prior to the signatures. Many new players were recruited whilst they are current players doing well at the same position. It’s high time that Orlando Pirates should consider the inputs from supporters as they can add positive value going forward.

I’m closing my argument with Julio Leal famous catchphrase which has been slightly modified to befit the situation.

“My article couldn’t not see any way forward and am offering the Chairman of Orlando Pirates Dr. Irvin Khoza to do what is right for the club’’ by either replacing Augusto “Njenje” Palacios with another coach possessing tactical soccer acumen or keep the coach for another few games with an expectation of performance to improve for better but personally, I prefer the ‘’former’’ over the ‘’latter’’ option.

By Owen Mundalamo

Tweet: @shudulizah
Founder: Football Food for Thought (FFT)

No comments:

Post a Comment